Meat & Wool Innovation  
Home Farm Tech Markets Training Quality Sheep & Wool Economic Service
NewsInnovation Magazine   Media About Us Links Sitemap
Home > Media

1 September 2003

Media Release
 

Meat and wool referendum a resounding 'yes' on all counts

New Zealand farmers have voted resoundingly to continue funding red meat and wool industry-good activities through a compulsory levy under the Commodity Levies Act 1990, and to form a single meat and wool organisation.  A clear majority also voted to retain reserves and continue investing in biotechnology.
 
Meat New Zealand chairman, Jeff Grant said: "The vote result is a strong mandate for the single organisation.  The turnout was good, and the clear majorities on all counts show farmers fully support the industry-good proposals."

 The industry-good activities include trade access, research and development, and market development for red meat, and education and training.

 

On weighted stock numbers, 76% and 77% voted for the sheepmeat and beef proposals respectively, 72% for wool, and 67% for goatmeat.  SheepCo chairman, Mike Petersen said: "These results are a clear mandate for industry related activities." 

 

Petersen and Grant said the results showed farmers had fully endorsed the concept of the single organisation.  Petersen said: "Right from the start we had a strong message from farmers that they wanted a single organisation with a different approach, and 80% of them supported it in the vote."

 

"This is a fresh start for industry-good." said Grant.  "Farmers wanted a change, and the single organisation will give them that - it has to be more accountable to farmers, with annual consultation about the levy rate.  The five-yearly farmer vote under the CLA is the ultimate test."

 

The Commodity Levies Act (CLA) votes for sheepmeat, beef, goatmeat and wool, were successful on both a one-farm-one-vote count, and on a weighted stock number count.  The CLA requires that both thresholds are passed by a simple majority before a levy order can be applied for. 

 

The votes in favour are as follows (given as one-farm-one-vote, then weighted stock number): sheepmeat 72% and 76%; beef 74% and 77%; wool 68% and 72%, goatmeat 67% and 67%.

 

Three additional questions asked of red meat producers were also successful on both counts.  The questions were on establishing the single organisation, keeping reserves, and investing in biotechnology. 

 

The votes in favour are as follows (given as one-farm-one-vote, then weighted stock number): single organisation 77% and 80%; reserves 68% and 70%; biotechnology 69% and 72%.

 

Grant said:  "Reserves provide an important safety net for farmers.  $52 million is set aside as an emergency fund in case we need to restore consumer confidence in red meat for any reason.  The reserves also provide a way to invest in biotechnology now, to deliver benefit to the next generation of farmers." 

 

Grant said he was satisfied with the turnout.  "Historically the CLA hasn't had really high numbers participating.  So I was pleased to hear that farmers representing over sixty percent of national stock numbers had voted."   Of the 33,714 farmers sent voting papers, 37% (12,591) cast votes, representing 62% of total production.  This represents 67% of sheep numbers, 58% of beef, 23% of dairy cattle, and 68% of goats.

 

The referendum was managed by an independent company, election.com Ltd, and an independent scrutineer, a Justice of the Peace, reviewed the process.

 

The next step is for the single organisation to apply to the Minister for a levy order.  Although this may take some time, the levy order is not planned to be effective until July 2004.  In the interim the current meat and wool levy collection arrangements continue under existing legislation.

 

For more information:

 

Jeff Grant (Chairman, Meat New Zealand) 027 431 5330

Mike Petersen (Chairman, SheepCo) 021 243 7344

Katie Mathison (Manager, Communications & Public Affairs) 021 899 129

 

Copies of the levy proposals and the constitution of the new organisation are available on www.farmerschoice.co.nz.


2003 FARMER'S CHOICE CLA REFERENDA

Final Results (Provisional)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CLA LEVY QUESTIONS

One Person  One Vote

Weighted

Result

 

 

Yes

Yes %

No

No %

Yes

Yes %

No

No%

CARRIED/LOST

 

Sheepmeat Levy

6,833

72.1%

2,647

27.9%

83,936

76.1%

26,377

23.9%

Carried

 

Beef Levy

7,894

73.8%

2,797

26.2%

52,619

76.6%

16,075

23.4%

Carried

 

Goatmeat Levy

414

67.0%

204

33.0%

533

67.2%

260

32.8%

Carried

 

Wool Levy

6,396

67.8%

3,037

32.2%

79,131

71.8%

31,039

28.2%

Carried

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NON-CLA QUESTIONS

One Person  One Vote

Weighted

Result

 

 

Yes

Yes %

No

No %

Yes

Yes %

No

No%

CARRIED/LOST

 

Establish Single Organisation

9,477

76.7%

2,875

23.3%

143,036

80.3%

35,150

19.7%

Carried

 

Retain Reserves

8,309

68.1%

3,890

31.9%

124,351

69.7%

53,969

30.3%

Carried

 

Biotechnology Investment

8,216

69.5%

3,606

30.5%

123,616

71.6%

49,012

28.4%

Carried

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RESPONSE RATE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* The 12,591 voter response represents:

 

 

 

* The 12,591 voter response represents:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

    % of National Sheep Numbers

67%

 

 

 

% of Sheep Farmers

63%

 

 

    % of National Beef Cattle Numbers

58%

 

 

 

% of Beef Farmers

 

59%

 

 

    % of National Dairy Cattle Numbers

23%

 

 

 

% of Dairy Farmers

 

18%

 

 

    % of National Goat Numbers

68%

 

 

 

Goat Farmers

 

650

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* Based on 2002 AgCensus numbers

 

 

 

(These are as a percentage of farmers - with over 250 sheep/goats, 100 Dairy & 50 Beef Cattle)

 

 

 

2003 FARMER'S CHOICE CLA REFERENDA

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Non CLA Questions -  Final Results by Stock Type  (Provisional)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Establish Single Organisation

One Person  One Vote

Weighted

 

 

Yes

Yes %

No

No %

Yes

Yes %

No

No%

 

Sheep

7,202

77.0%

2,157

23.0%

87,440

80.1%

21,698

19.9%

 

Beef

7,047

78.0%

1,982

22.0%

44,814

80.8%

10,663

19.2%

 

Dairy

2,053

77.6%

594

22.4%

10,143

79.7%

2,583

20.3%

 

Goats

476

74.4%

164

25.6%

639

75.6%

206

24.4%

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Retain Reserves

One Person  One Vote

Weighted

 

 

Yes

Yes %

No

No %

Yes

Yes %

No

No%

 

Sheep

6,196

66.2%

3,162

33.8%

74,777

68.3%

34,744

31.7%

 

Beef

6,199

68.6%

2,833

31.4%

39,799

71.3%

15,989

28.7%

 

Dairy

1,866

73.4%

676

26.6%

9,197

75.6%

2,961

24.4%

 

Goats

430

66.2%

220

33.8%

578

67.8%

275

32.2%

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Biotechnology Investment

One Person  One Vote

Weighted

 

 

Yes

Yes %

No

No %

Yes

Yes %

No

No%

 

Sheep

6,172

68.1%

2,895

31.9%

74,741

70.5%

31,230

29.5%

 

Beef

6,062

69.2%

2,698

30.8%

38,937

72.1%

15,098

27.9%

 

Dairy

1,850

75.0%

616

25.0%

9,373

79.6%

2,402

20.4%

 

Goats

421

66.0%

217

34.0%

565

66.9%

280

33.1%

 


 

 

Copyright © Meat & Wool Innovation Ltd.

Home | Farm Tech | Markets | Training | Quality | Sheep & Wool | Economic Service
News | Magazine | Media | About Us | Links | Sitemap